Modern man is asked by the zeitgeist of the times to live life open-minded and accepting of multiple possible world views and perspectives. In today's pluralistic culture of the West, to believe that there is one correct view on life and morals is considered closed-minded. Relativism in the West opens our minds to multiple simultaneous and contradicting truths. Multiple perspectives on life and truth are valued even if contradicting. This type of mindset can be confusing, but confusion is the home of the modern mind. Instead of confusion one can call it possibility, potential, freedom. In this state though, our perspective on life is much like this painting by Picasso, The Poet. Its hard to know what we are looking at, but one is supposed to be ok with that and find the beauty in ambiguity. This is the mind of modern man, he doesn't know what we are or where we are going but isn't that kind of pretty in itself, just the weird wonder of it? Concrete meaning and definite truths are blurred and blended. What is truth? What is man? What is God? What is reality?
Cubism paints reality from multiple perspectives at once, after all one perspective can't be right. All perspectives at once are true even if this leads to no perspective. This type of painting can be a metaphor for the mental state of how reality appears to the modern man who is open to all-truths since no truth is absolutely true to everyone. Being open to all-truths, even contradictory truths is like having no truth.
Representational art traditionally has one viewpoint. Traditionally societies have had a majority viewpoint. Art tended to have meaning and represented real things and ideas. As in cubism, the modern liberal mind tends to shun a single narrative of truth unless that narrative is that there is no one truth. Ambiguity, open-mindedness, pluralism, "tolerance", is the ideal. I think that is why modern art is so ambiguous and hard to understand. Modern Western society thinks life should be hard to understand, at least a life with meaning. It tends to say that each person makes his or her own personal meaning and no one narrative encompasses all as true.
Then we have abstract expressionism. This type of art seems to promote the idea that meaning is not important in life, only self-expression and freedom to do whatever you feel. The need to communicate ideas and connect to others in a rational way is not important. What seems to be encouraged is the expression of the self at the expense of a shared experience with others with actual understood meaning. Can you think of any people in your life that live this way?
Am I reading to much into art and what its style promotes or can you see that values of a society materialized in the artworks it creates?
2 comments:
Just read your testimony in the 'Coming Home Network' June 2015 newsletter. Wonderful! A lot of resonance there (would like to chat private with you on this later). Meanwhile, in this piece regarding art, you may also like to consider the role of iconography.
Iconography is not actually art at all. It is prayer. It is sacred. And yes, in natural terms, mankind may of course categorize iconography in terms of art. But this is missing the point, for to see the reality submerged within an icon, one must enter the hidden world of prayer.
And this prayerful state is not to 'God by any name you call him', but to the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ. Specific, pin-pointed to time and space; this is indeed the mystery of the Incarnation, drawing together the spiritual untouchable realm of God's majestic throne, and the very earthy life of Jesus: miraculously conceived by the power of the Holy Spirit, born of to a young Jewish maiden -the Blessed Virgin Mary- suffered under Pontius Pilate, and crucified in a terribly agonizing manner, suffering with the weight and guilt of the sins of the world upon Him. The reality of his resurrection and ascension, the descent of the Holy Spirit, and the mystery of the world to come, and the return of Christ – these are spiritual mysteries to which men and women desire to find – but for as long as they seek pluralism, will miss. May the Holy Spirit draw them to the Cross!
It is an unspeakable mystery, an unfathomable sorrow, and an unimaginable joy to be invited to be children of God, joint heirs with Christ, and partakers of His Resurrection.
To me, this paints the picture of our Catholic Christian faith, handed down to us through the ages and now ours to participate in and share to our own generations. To me, this too is the inner beauty of icons.
Many blessings,
John Ruffle
Former Jesus Freak, and Pentecostal; received into the Catholic Church Easter Vigil 2013
http://rufflemission.org
Thanks for taking time to read my story and blog posts. I like your thoughts on icons. I hope we can talk more about our faith journeys.
Post a Comment